Papa John’s is the fourth-largest pizza delivery chain in the U.S. It has over 5,500 locations worldwide and many pizza choices to offer.
The pizza prices and sizes from Papa John’s give their customers the freedom to choose which pizza they order according to their needs, whether a small or a group meal.
Papa John’s offers small, medium, large, and extra-large pizzas that you can enjoy. I love the iconic cheese pizzas, and I almost always order that pizza from Papa John’s.
While the prices of pizzas at Papa John’s are relatively average and affordable, we have to note that U.S. prices vary significantly compared to other branches in other countries.
Pizza is not the only thing you can get from Papa John’s. There are also these amazing sides that we will be tackling in this post.
So whether you are just having a simple pizza meal at home or want a pizza party, Papa John’s has you covered with its amazing pizza prices and sizes.
All About Papa John’s
Just like most pizza chains, Papa John’s started out as a small business that caters to the nearby neighborhood. “Papa” John Schnatter started out this pizza chain in 1984.
Papa John’s started in Schnatter’s tavern where he used $1600 worth of pizza equipment. The pizza gained popularity within 9 years, it grew from a small pizza tavern to 500 stores.
In 1997, Papa John’s even grew larger, with over 1,500 stores. They continued branching out until they had stores all over the country.
Perhaps what kick-started Papa John’s popularity during the 2010s was that two of its branches were bought through bitcoin.
To this day, fans still celebrate that purchase with what they call “Bitcoin Pizza Day”. It was a huge marketing move; as we can see, Papa John’s is also popular online.
Papa John’s also started online delivery in January of 2002, making pizza available to any customer they have no matter where they are.
They also tried the “Papa Priority,” where you pay $2.99 to jump at the front of the line when ordering. So these tricks, trades, and promos, along with their pizzas, made Papa John’s popular.
There are different pizza sizes to try from Papa John’s as well as flavors and toppings that everybody loves so you will not run out of options.
Papa John’s Pizza Sizes
There are four pizza sizes when you order pizza from Papa John’s. You can either get a small pizza, a medium pizza, a large pizza, or an extra large pizza.
- Small – The small pizza from Papa John’s is 8 inches in diameter and is good for 2 or 3 people. You can change the pizza crust type that you want as well.
- Medium – Medium pizza is 12 inches in diameter and can feed 4 to 5 people. It is not that big but it is a good family meal if you want a pizza for your next dinner.
- Large – If you have some friends over, a large pizza will fit your meal. Papa John’s large pizza is 14 inches and can feed 5 to 7 people.
- Extra Large – Extra-large pizzas are for parties with a diameter of 16 to 18 inches and can feed up to 8 pizza lovers.
While you can order by size, you can also base your order on how many slices there are in the pizza that you order.
Number Of Slices In Papa John’s Pizza
Papa John’s pretty much uses a standard number of slices on each of their pizza slices. The small pizza has 6 slices, while the medium and large have 8 slices.
If you order the extra-large pizza for a large group of people, you can get 10 slices. So based on the number of slices, you will have an idea of how many pizzas to order.
| Papa John’s Pizza Sizes | Number Of Slices |
| Small | 6 |
| Medium | 8 |
| Large | 8 |
| Extra-large | 10 |
When you order online, there is no part on the customization page where you can edit the number of slices that comes with your pizza.
However, you can select the type of cut you want your pizza. You can select from the normal, clean, square, or no-cut pizza crust.
Papa John’s Pizza Prices
Aside from the size and number of slices, you can choose what type of pizza you want. With different toppings to choose from, you can create the pizza of your choice.
The toppings have different prices, which translates to the pizza price as a whole. With curated pizzas, the only thing that changes in the price is when you select a different pizza size.
Here is a simple table that shows how those price changes depending on the type of pizza you order and what size the pizza you order is.
| Papa John’s Pizza | Small | Medium | Large | Extra Large |
| Pepperoni | $12.50 | $14.90 | $17.10 | $20.30 |
| Sausage | $12.50 | $14.90 | $17.10 | $20.30 |
| Cheese | $12.50 | $14.90 | $17.10 | $20.30 |
| The Works | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
| The Meats | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
| Zesty Italian Trio | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
| Meatball Pepperoni | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
| Super Hawaiian | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
| Ultimate Pepperoni | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
| BBQ Chicken Bacon | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
| Fiery Buffalo Chicken | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
| Philly Cheesesteak | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
| Pepperoni. Sausage & 6 Cheese | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
| Extra Cheesy Alfredo | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
| Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
| Garden Fresh | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
| Tuscan Six Cheese | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
| Hawaiian BBQ Chicken | $14.49 | $17.19 | $19.19 | $23.49 |
Note: The pizzas listed above are based on the prices of the pizzas made with Papa John’s original crust. The prices vary on the type of crust that you select.
Not all pizza crusts are available in all sizes as well. For instance, small pizzas can only be ordered with the original and gluten-free crust.
Here is another table that shows you what pizza sizes you can order from Papa John’s and what type of pizza crust is available in each size.
| Size | Original Crust | Epic Pepperoni Stuffed | NY Style Crust | Epic Stuffed Crust | Thin Crust | Gluten-free Crust |
| Small | YES | NO | NO | NO | NO | NO |
| Medium | YES | NO | NO | NO | NO | NO |
| Large | YES | YES | NO | YES | YES | NO |
| Extra-large | YES | NO | YES | NO | NO | NO |
Papa John’s Sides Prices
Again, pizza is not the only treat you can order from Papa John’s. They also have sides that you can enjoy with your pizza meal.
Some more popular sides are the savory garlic knots, breadsticks, and jalapeno popper rolls. Other sides go well with the pizzas that they have.
| Papa John’s Sides | Price |
| Jalapeno Popper Rolls | $7.00 |
| Garlic Knots | $7.00 |
| Original Breadsticks | $7.00 |
| Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks | $8.00 |
| Cheesesticks | $7.49 |
| Bacon Cheesesticks | $8.49 |
| Tuscan 6-cheese Cheesesticks | $8.49 |
Papa John’s Dessert Prices
Now, to finish off your meal, you can get the desserts from Papa John’s. There are three available desserts from the menu that you can choose from.
| Papa John’s Dessert | Price |
| Cinnamon Pull Aparts | $7.19 |
| Chocolate Chip Cookie | $7.19 |
| Double Chocolate Chip Brownie | $7.19 |
My favorite among these desserts is the chocolate chip cookie. I usually get my heavy meal from the pizza, and the sides and the chocolate chip cookie provide just enough sweetness without being too heavy in the stomach.
Double chocolate chip brownies are also great in terms of flavor but they are usually too heavy for me. However, I like ordering them for carry-out to enjoy at home.
How Many Pizzas Do I Order?
Before ordering pizza, I always count the people I will be feeding and the other important factors that go into ordering pizzas.
Since Papa John’s has 4 available sizes and specifies how many slices there are in each size, it makes it easier to know how many pizzas I should order.
Here are some of the basis of how many orders I should order:
How Many Persons To Feed
The rule of thumb is to order at least 3 slices for each person. Other factors aside, three slices of pizza should be enough for a person to have a fulfilling meal.
Some people might have a smaller appetite than others, so 3 slices are a safe play. If you are ordering for a hungry group, maybe account for another slice for each person.
Alternatively, you can settle with 3 slices per person, especially if you do not want too many leftover pizza slices.
Appetite
We have touched on this above, but you should also include it in the factors. If you are feeding an all-adult group, that would be easier.
However, kids that have smaller appetites will usually have leftovers. Accounting for 2 slices per kid will give you a rough estimate of how many pizzas you should order.
You can also opt for a thin-crust pizza that is not as heavy as the other crusts if the people you are feeding have smaller appetites.
Other Food
If you plan on serving food other than pizza, you can clock down to 2 slices per person. 3 slices of pizza for each person is estimated to satisfy the person’s appetite.
So if you have other heavy types of food like wings, sides, and even desserts, you can order fewer pizzas for the group.
Do You Want Leftovers?
I love leftover pizza because of its convenience. I can easily throw two slices in the microwave and have myself a delicious pizza meal within minutes.
Ordering too many pizzas can be good if you know how to store leftover pizza properly. If you are not a fan of leftovers, use the rough estimate of 3 slices per person.
That way, you will not have too many slices of pizza as leftovers and just put them to waste.
How Many Pizzas Do I Need
You can use this table to estimate how many pizzas and pizza slices you will need for your group.
| Number Of People | Number Of Pizza Slices | Number Of Pizzas |
| 5 | 15 | 2 |
| 10 | 30 | 4 |
| 15 | 45 | 6 |
| 20 | 60 | 8 |
| 25 | 75 | 10 |
You can also refer to this full guide by Green Lantern Pizza on how many pizzas you should order for your next pizza meal or pizza party.
Best Pizza To Buy At Papa John’s?
My favorite pizza from Papa John’s is the Garden Fresh pizza. It is a healthy option with only 200 calories per slice which is relatively lower than the meat pizzas.
While I would love to have included meat in the pizza, it is my favorite because it is light and delicious. It has a lot of crispy vegetables that make the pizza savory as well.
Loaded with peppers, onions, ripe black olives, and Crimini mushrooms, the Garden Fresh pizza from Papa John’s can make you eat more slices of pizza than you expect.
Although I love the Garden Fresh pizza, the cheese and pepperoni pizza from Papa John’s is still the undisputed favorite for most customers.
These flavor-filled pizzas are great if you want familiar flavors. The pepperoni pizza is loaded with meat that everybody loves.
The same goes for a cheese pizza with the savory flavors that make it a favorite of many. It is up to your preferences but for now, I’ll stick with the Garden Fresh pizza.
What Time Does Papa John’s Close?
Papa John’s closes late, with some branches staying open until 1 am. However, that depends on the branch and state you decide to order from.
Based on one of the more popular stores of Papa John’s (New York City, New York branch), here is the opening and closing times of Papa John’s.
| Day | Delivery | Carryout |
| Monday | 11 AM to 1 AM | 11 AM to 12:10 AM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM to 1 AM | 11 AM to 12:10 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM to 1 AM | 11 AM to 12:10 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM to 1 AM | 11 AM to 12:10 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM to 2 AM | 11 AM to 1:10 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM to 2 AM | 11 AM to 1:10 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM to 1 AM | 11 AM to 12:10 AM |
How Long Does Papa John’s Pizza Last In The Fridge?
So you have ordered too many pizzas, and now you have some leftover slices. The good thing is that you can store Papa John’s pizza in your fridge for up to 4 days.
According to the USDA, you can store cooked foods in your fridge for up to 3 to 4 days as long as you do the right steps.
When storing your leftover slices, the best way to store them is to wrap each slice with plastic wrap and then place them in an airtight container.
Place them in the fridge, and then you have pizza slices for up to 4 days. You can also extend that by putting the pizza slices in your freezer.
If you do not plan on eating the pizza anytime soon, it is best to store the pizza slices in your freezer so they can last for even longer – up to 2 months.
If you like the post, do not forget to share it on social media!
Leave a Reply