Cooking is such a complex yet simple task if you master it with consistent practice. Pizza is a recipe that makes cooking fun, so here is a list of the best toaster ovens for cooking pizza.
Many people have a problem with cooking pizza indoor which is the ovens do not generate high heat, but this problem can be solved with the help of toaster ovens as they cook fairly good pizzas.
This is why we think it was best to come out with this post on different kinds of toaster ovens that are out there, and in the case you like something mentioned on the list, make sure to check it out.
This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase through a link. Please see my full disclosure for further information.
Most of the toaster ovens mentioned here are best rated on amazon and have some great customer reviews. I personally think they well deserve all the love they are getting from their users.
Toaster ovens do take some time to cook a pizza but overall the taste pretty much feels the same. You may not get the Neapolitan style pizza with the leopard spotting but you can make something similar to dominos.
You do get a crisp base and a nicely cooked toppings and cheese which is all you need in order to have the perfect pizza.
The right tools, such as the baking stone and the right oven, are also important. You cannot just cook a pizza on weak cookware and then call it authentic because it will never be authentic.
That is why you need to compensate for the low heat that you cook pizzas in. This list of toaster ovens will guide you to make sure that you buy the right oven for cooking the best pizzas.
What Do You Need For A Pizza?
The first thing that you need to consider before buying cookware for pizza is the temperature. If you want it to be authentic, then I suggest that you stay away from conventional ovens and go for the best outdoor pizza ovens out there!
But toaster ovens have some pretty good results too. If you are looking for something that would help you make a decent pizza, then you should check out pizza ovens from this recommendation.
The right temperature for making authentic pizzas is at least 900 degrees Fahrenheit. Now, obviously, there are no toaster ovens that can get up to those temperatures. So it is still possible.
In order to compensate for that, you will need to cook the pizza for a longer period of time. See, authentic pizza is cooked in just seconds or in just one minute to consider it authentic.
The fast cooking time is meant for the crust and to keep it crispy. The quick change in temperature immediately evaporates the unnecessary moisture from the pizza and its crust.
Now, obviously, the toaster ovens on this list cannot reach that temperature. So we chose the best ones that you can find in the market so that you can make the pizza as good as it can be.
There are also a lot of things that you need to consider before buying any of the ones listed below, but we will talk about that by the end of the post, so let us get into the ovens themselves.
1. Cuisinart Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven
Starting off with a big toaster oven, the Cuisinart Chef’s Toaster Oven is one that functions like any oven. However, it has features that make it different from others and make it great for pizza.
This pizza oven measures roughly around 20 by 16 by 11 inches which means that it is going to take up a lot of space. So I recommend getting this for bigger households with a lot of space.
The setup will be pretty easy as you will only need to plug it into a nearby electrical outlet. The only challenge is the space that it needs to be set up to accommodate the large oven.
Excluding the insulation, this toaster oven has a large interior. In fact, with its interior, you will be able to fit up to 9 slices of toast or roast a whole chicken in it with a little bit of extra space.
That means that it can cook up to 13 inches of pizza. This is great if you are having a dinner party with your friends as it will be able to cook ample amounts of food in just minutes.
The maximum temperature of this toaster oven is 350 degrees Fahrenheit which means that in less than 15 minutes, your pizza will be ready with perfectly cooked crust and even toppings.
2. Panasonic FlashXpress
Now if you have a small kitchen and you do not have that much space for the larger oven mentioned above, then this toaster oven will surely get you to cook pizzas in smaller portions.
The FlashXpress is a small toaster oven with powerful features that will still get you to cook food like you are cooking in larger conventional ovens. It is the best oven for its size, in my opinion.
The first things that I tried cooking in this oven are frozen goods and baked goods. It did not take long for me to get familiar with its functions and see what it can do with other foods.
The well-balanced insulation gave way for even cooking. This means that no matter where you put your food, it will always cook evenly because of the absence of any hot or cold spots.
For its size, it truly is powerful as it made toasts faster than most models that I have tried. However, I was considering if it was because of its size or the actual heat that it produces.
It is only around 1 cubic foot in volume which means that you will not need a large area for the setup. This kind of space will give you just enough room to toast about four slices of bread.
This toaster oven can also get up to 350 degrees Fahrenheit.
With its size, I would recommend using it for preheating pizzas for smaller portions but nothing is stopping you from cooking fresh ones in it.
3. Breville Compact Smart Oven
The middle ground for the two ovens listed above is this one. It is slightly larger than the FlashXpress but is smaller than the Cuisinart toaster oven so it will fit in most kitchens.
One thing that this oven boasts is the Element IQ technology that was installed in it. It offers ease of control for you and will accurately set the timer and temperature for the users.
This oven is one of the most impressive ovens that I have ever tried. I consider it the best oven when it comes to heat retention or at least in maintaining the set temperature on it.
This means that if you use this oven, you will be able to cook any food in it at the same set temperature. Even if you open its doors, the temperature will come back almost instantly when closed.
With just enough heat to cook pizzas for 15 minutes, this oven will allow you to also get foods cooked fast. It melts cheese perfectly and gives a slightly crispy crust on bread and dough.
The intuitive interface is what I liked the most about this oven. It gives you the best kind of control compared to most toaster ovens so you can cook with ease and precision.
4. Kitchenaid Digital Countertop Toaster Oven
Keeping up with technological advances is not that easy, but then, it is also not that hard if you have this toaster oven. It has one of the most easy-to-use interfaces in any oven right now.
It is made with digital controls with preset temperatures and timers. That way, you will no longer need to research the right temperature and set it yourself as it is only one click of a button away.
Such preset features are ones meant for cooking bagels, cookies, roasting chicken, toast, bake and broil. This means that you will be easily cooking any food with just one click.
With that said, it also has a feature that allows you to cook pizzas in just minutes. The preset temperature goes to its maximum and then cooks the pizza within ten minutes depending on the thickness.
This toaster oven is also large enough to fit up to 9 slices of bread, however, the company recommends only six. That way, you will still have enough space to turn the bread if needed.
The other feature that involves control is the start and cancel buttons. These, I think are underrated because they are very convenient when you need the oven to stop right away.
There are also no complicated displays on this oven. The straightforward and clear display at the bottom of the oven will give you the precise time and temperature that your food is cooked.
5. The June Oven
Now, if you want to talk about technological advancements, then this oven really is the one. It has features unlike any other oven that you have ever seen and it offers maximum ease of use.
The functionality of this oven is not that complicated, however, you might get confused on the first tries. The features of this oven will give you goosebumps when you first cook in it.
So this is how the oven functions, first, you put the food in the oven. Once it is in there, close the door and then just allow the oven to do its thing, no more pressing buttons or setting timers.
This is because the June Oven has a camera inside it. When you put the food inside, it reads or captures it and then recommends the settings that suggest how to cook the food it sees.
You can then just press the start button to allow the preset settings to cook the food. Now, this can be troublesome if the food is slightly complicated so you do have other options.
When you want other ways to cook the food inside the oven, you can totally override the controls and then set the temperature and timer to the best setting that you know of.
This oven does not have buttons as it offers a touchpad for the override controls. The touchpad is so fast and is set to respond as fast as an iPhone which is really convenient.
With this toaster oven, you will be able to cook at least a 12-inch pizza in it. With enough room to cook up to 12 slices of bread and roast a large chicken or even a turkey inside.
6. Hamilton Beach Sure-crisp Air Fry Toaster Oven
If you want a toaster oven with unique cooking capabilities, then this one’s for you. It offers a lot of features and functions a little bit like the conventional ovens that you are used to.
Yes, it does look like the basic oven with the turning controls on the side and bland stainless steel color. However, looks are truly deceiving as this toaster oven is more advanced than you think.
Within minutes, you will be able to cook pizzas with evenly finished toppings and nicely melted cheese. The convection inside this oven is impressive and is perfect for any kind of food.
The interior of this toaster oven is also reasonably large. With what it offers, you will actually be able to cook 13-inch pizzas in this oven so it is great for a small pizza dinner for the family.
Now, the air-frying capabilities of this oven are also impressive. You can cook other foods in it so that you will have something to pair with your pizza and make the meal even more enjoyable.
The air fryer of this toaster oven was able to produce chicken wings that were crispy on all sides. It also uses the heat properly so the food does not really dry out inside.
7. Cuisinart Air Fryer and Toaster Oven
Back to one of the most well-known oven companies in the market. Cuisinart truly sets the standard for toaster ovens as they put up one great oven after another and consistently satisfy users.
This oven might seem complicated at first but you will quickly get familiar with it. It includes 13 different cooking functions so you can select the settings easily when you want to cook a specific recipe.
The air fryer also gives you up to five options including dehydration, roast, and dual cook. That means that you can fry anything that you want in it and you do not have to control it that much.
With its powerful heat, it can cook fried chicken and fries in just minutes. The results came in with the most exceptional flavor and juicy chicken wings with crispy skins.
As for the pizza, this oven did not have any trouble cooking it. I tried this oven with a loaded pizza full of toppings and within 10 minutes, it was able to cook it with a crispy crust.
I did have some trouble getting the right finish on the toppings as there are times when they dried out. The simple solution is to put a little bit more sauce and cover it with cheese.
I find it best to cook frozen pizza in this oven since it retains the moisture. Just do not turn the air fryer options on and your frozen pizza will become as delicious as a fresh one.
8. Ninja Foodi Digital Air Fryer Toaster Oven
It is really important to consider the space where you will put an oven before buying it. This toaster oven from Ninja Foodi will surely give you enough space along with cooking prowess.
One of the best features of this toaster oven is the flip-up option. It is a rectangular oven that you can flip right side up so that it becomes more compact and great for small storage.
With this option, you will be able to bring it out only when needed and save some space for other appliances. This is helpful since you are not going to use the oven every time you cook a meal.
Another feature of this appliance is the removable bottom surface. This allows you to go deep in the oven and clean it thoroughly after using it giving you a clean oven the next time you cook.
The space in the interior is also enough for you to cook 11-inch pizzas. Within minutes, this toaster oven was able to produce the best pizzas with a crispy crust and evenly cooked toppings.
9. Breville Smart Toaster Oven
This toaster oven is a large oven that will feed a whole family with guests. It can fit up to 9 slices of bread inside and cook them with precision and speed on any recipe that you want.
Think of it as a smaller version of the full-sized pizza oven. It produces enough heat to roast, bake, or toast food which is very beneficial if you want to cook pizzas frequently.
The other option on this toaster oven is where you can even use it as an air fryer. That means that cooking and drying out your meat toppings a little bit before placing them on the pizza is possible.
It is also packed with presets which means that you will rarely need to set the exact temperature and time for your food. Just select the designated preset for the food and it will cook immediately.
Things To Consider Before Buying A Toaster Oven
Before actually buying a toaster oven or any product for that matter, you will need to consider some things. Choose the best one by weighing the options using a simple guide such as this.
Again, the first thing that you need to consider before buying a toaster oven is the space. You will need the right amount of space to set up the oven while giving you room to prep the food.
Space also suggests the actual space inside the oven that you are going to buy. That way, you will know how much food you can cook in it or how large of a pizza you can place inside.
Now, if you have a large kitchen, then do not hesitate to get the bigger options. Smaller options are great for cooking a simple meal for the family but bigger ones will be good for having guests.
In order to maximize the space inside the oven, you will need to choose the product with most racks included in it. That way, you have multiple tiers for cooking multiple foods at a time.
Since toaster ovens use convection for heating up the interior, the temperature will be even on any rack. That means that you will be able to cook at least two pizzas at a time in dual racks.
This is not that important but if you really want to make your cooking experience easier, then I suggest that you buy a toaster oven with as many accessories as you can.
Choose the toaster oven that offers many accessories so that you will not have to buy them from other stores. Save the hassle in both shopping and cooking with the best accessories.
Heat Retention and Maximum Temperature
This is something that I look for in every pizza oven and hence I would recommend that you do so as well. The maximum temperature the toaster oven can attain is just as important.
You might want to check that on the specifications of the oven and make sure that you are getting a toaster oven that gets pretty hit. This is a one time investment so make sure you get something that you would use often.
Most of the ovens that we have mentioned in the post are durable so they are going to last for a really long time but always double check before you are handed over something that would just be sitting on your kitchen countertop.
Since these are toaster ovens the cooking time is going to be longer in comparison to the outdoor pizza ovens that cook pizzas extremely quickly.
Outdoor pizza ovens are probably one of the best pizza ovens out there for cooking Neapolitan pizzas. If cooking outdoors is not an issue then you can definitely try out the Ooni Koda or the Ooni karu pizza ovens.
Anything from the Ooni series or the Roccbox Pizza Oven if you are interested in a multi-fueled pizza oven. Ooni Pizza Ovens cook pizzas within 60 seconds which is pretty amazing considering how many pizzas you can make inside this oven in 5 minutes.
However, not everyone has the space outdoors which is needed to cook pizzas in the Ooni Pizza Oven since it is an outdoor pizza oven so cooking a pizza in a toaster oven will take around 10-15 minutes but you are not going to be disappointed with the end result.
Cooking pizzas is not an easy task to do as it involves a lot of practice. However, if you have a toaster oven like the ones mentioned above, then the job will be so much easier.
So make sure to consider all the tips above and choose the best toaster oven that you think will fit your preferences. That way, you will not have to deal with space issues and cooking functions.
Again, practice is the keyword here so get the best toaster oven that you want and then cook again and again. Do not be afraid to fail as soon enough, you will be making the best pizzas with these toaster ovens.
It is a bit of a learning curve when it comes to cooking anything in an oven so make sure you give it some time before you are able to make some perfect pizzas.
If you like the post then do not forget to share it on social media!