How To Reheat Little Caesars Pizza (In just 5 minutes!)

Everybody loves little Caesar’s pizza whether it is the deep-dish pizza, stuff crust, or the other options, we all love it. Now you’re here to learn how to reheat Little Caesar’s pizza.

Since we all love these pizzas from Little Caesar’s pizza, it is not uncommon that we get a little ahead of ourselves and order pizza one too many and now you have some leftovers.

You must store the pizza properly so you can reheat it later on. This makes for a good meal when your friends come over and you want to cook something quickly.

If you store the pizza after eating, you shouldn’t leave it in the box that it came from. It will be better to find a container to place it in and store it properly in the fridge or the freezer.

You can reheat frozen pizza the next day for a great meal. If you have your friends over the next day, you can reheat Little Caesar’s pizza in a regular oven and it will taste just as great.

There are also other ways to reheat Little Caesar’s pizza like in the microwave oven, in the air fryer, or a toaster oven. Either way, we will be teaching you how to reheat it properly.

Table of Contents

How To Reheat Little Caesar’s Pizza In The Oven?

I would say that reheating Little Caesar’s pizza in the oven is the best way to reheat it. If you have a frozen pizza, this is certainly the best way to reheat it to make sure that it heats up all around.

Some people suggest that you reheat pizza in the oven at 400 degrees Fahrenheit to get that crispy crust, and I would also recommend this if you only refrigerated the pizza.

If you got a Little Caesar’s pizza and made it into a frozen pizza, it is better to go with lower temperatures first. You can also reheat the pizza in the oven without aluminum foil.

Reheating the pizza in the oven at 400 degrees Fahrenheit can be too hot for the pizza and the middle part will not heat up properly. So I recommend you reheat it in the oven at lower than 400 degrees.

Here are the simple steps to reheat pizza in the oven without foil:

1. Preheat the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit.

2. Place the pan or better yet, pizza stone inside the oven to preheat it as well for at least 15 minutes. You will need the pan to reheat the pizza in the oven without a foil.

3. Place the pizza on the pan and then close the oven door.

4. At 350 degrees Fahrenheit, you should reheat the pizza for at least 10 minutes.

5. You can go longer than 10 minutes to make the pizza crust even crispier.

6. Once you get the right crispiness that you want, you can then remove the pizza from the oven and let it cool for a little at room temperature before serving it.

How To Reheat Litte Caesar’s Pizza In A Toaster Oven

While you can reheat Little Caesar’s pizza in the air fryer, I still think the oven toaster does a better job.

It can make the crust of the pizza crispier and it can fit more slices at the same time.

Given that a toaster oven is not that large, you can still put more slices of pizza to reheat in it than in the air fryer.

This is a more convenient way to reheat a few slices instead of the whole pizza in the box.

Since a toaster oven uses convection heat, it works just like an oven and will give you similar results.

The longer you reheat the Little Caesar’s pizza in it, the crispier it will get.

That is unless, of course, you overcook it. Make sure to turn your timer on and set the right temperature on the toaster oven when you reheat the pizza so it does not get overcooked.

That goes with the thin-crust pizza, deep-dish pizza, and other types of pizza from Little Caesar’s.

The deep-dish pizza will need a longer cooking time but you still need to look after it.

Reheating Little Caesar’s pizza in the toaster oven:

Preheat the toaster oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit.
Preheat the pizza stone inside the oven as well for 15 minutes.
Put the slices of pizzas that you want to reheat on the pizza stone.
Allow the slices of pizza to reheat for at least 10 minutes.
Serve once it is cool enough to handle.

How To Reheat Little Caesar’s Pizza In The Microwave Oven

There is a contradicting audience when reheating pizza in the microwave oven. While most college students stand by it because of its convenience, some do not recommend it.

I stand with the latter if you do not want to make a soggy mess with the pizza dough from Little Caesar’s. It can either go with a soggy crust or the crust will turn out to be too hard and dry.

If there are other methods available, you should use those. It is really hard to adjust to reheating the pizza in the microwave oven as you get inconsistent results.

You can either get a burnt crust if the temperature is too high or go with a soggy, flavorless, dry crust when you go with lower temperatures.

Reheating Little Caesar’s Pizza In The Microwave Oven

Place the pizza slices you want to reheat on a microwave-safe plate.
Get a microwave-safe cup and fill it with water to retain the moisture of the pizza.
Set the microwave oven on high heat and then reheat the pizza for 30 to 45 seconds.
Remove the pizza from the microwave and then brush some olive oil or butter on top.

How To Reheat Little Caesar’s Pizza On A Stovetop

Reheating Little Caesar’s pizza on a pan is slightly risky since you might not be able to adjust the heat around the pizza. You do need a balanced source of heat to cook the toppings.

The most common problem is that you might burn the pizza crust without even heating the pizza toppings, and that is why you need to make adjustments to this method.

The only way that you will be able to balance the heat from the stove to the top part is to create a dome that will heat the air so that the toppings will cook simultaneously as the crust.

You do not have to worry that much about the bottom part of the crust as it comes into contact with the heat from the pan. The main problem is the toppings so here is how to do it.

Reheating Little Caesar’s Pizza On The Stovetop

Get a cast-iron skillet and heat it on the stovetop over medium heat.
Place the pizza slice that you want to reheat on the skillet and then let it heat up for 2 minutes with the lid on.
Put a few drops of water on the skillet but not directly on the pizza itself.
Place the lid back on to let the water create steam.
Once the cheese has melted, remove the pizza from the skillet and serve it.

How To Store Little Caesar’s Pizza Leftovers

It is best to store your leftover pizza right away and not leave it in the box that it came in with. Your takeout pizza should not be left on the counter for more than 2 hours or it will be unsafe to eat.

First of all, the cold pizza will attract bacteria that can be dangerous. The leftover pizza slices should also be taken care of and wrapped in plastic wrap or aluminum foil before storing them.

Whether you order from Domino’s, Pizza Hut, Papa John’s Pizza, or any other pizza chain, you still need to make sure that the pizza leftovers do not go stale on the countertop.

These heating methods above are economical ways to save your food while keeping the quality. After wrapping each pizza slice in foil, place them in the refrigerator.

Make sure to cook it the next day or within 3 days as they will likely turn bad if you leave them in the fridge for more than 4 days.

Follow the heating methods above and do not be afraid to add some additional minutes if you want to make the pizza crispier like a fresh pizza, but do not overcook them.

Your best option is to reheat the pizza in the oven so you still get that fresh flavors even with 3-day old pizzas. These are not your only options as you can also use the air fryer for reheating if you only need one slice.

Find what is available to you and make sure to reheat the pizza properly to kill all the bacteria in it before enjoying a slice!

If you like the post then do not forget to share it on social media!